| League | Team | Owner | Record |
|---|
| American Association | Buckeye Bombers | David Henning | 22-26 (.458) |
| American Association | Cleveland Spiders | Michael Rudolph | 22-26 (.458) |
| Anchorman League | Cooperstown Wannabes | David Henning | 23-25 (.479) |
| B Movie Actor League | Don't Let Me Down | Jason Kiernan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Beatleball | Ringo's Stars | Michael Rudolph | 21-27 (.438) |
| Beer League | Goose Island 312 Chicago Microbrew | Jason Kiernan | 17-31 (.354) |
| Birdland | Bird Droppings | John Stroba | 22-26 (.458) |
| Blame Canada League | Fairplays Hubba-baloo | Jason Kiernan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Blame Canada League | Frigid Pink Ladies of the Artic Night | Jamie Reese | 18-30 (.375) |
| Blame Canada League | Thunder Bay Voyageurs | Jerry Stevens | 20-28 (.417) |
| Bleed Dodger Blue | Brooklyn Blues | Alonda Clifton | 13-35 (.271) |
| Blue and Gray League | Bradford Bluecoats | Michael Lehman | 22-26 (.458) |
| Blue and Gray League | Savannah Sand Gnats | Daniel Foley, Jr. | 20-28 (.417) |
| Born to Run League | Central City Flashes | David Henning | 19-29 (.396) |
| British Invasion League | Abbey Road Revolution | David Henning | 17-31 (.354) |
| British Invasion League | Band of Brothers & Their AC DC Oasis Reunion | John Hula | 22-26 (.458) |
| Broadway League | Rocky Horror Picture Show | Andrew Lehman | 17-31 (.354) |
| Broadway League | Times Square Pickpockets | Jon Swanson | 23-25 (.479) |
| Bronx Bombers League | Chandeliers On The Hood | Sherman Wan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Cleveland Rocks | Not So Hot In Cleveland | Andrew Lehman | 19-29 (.396) |
| Experts League | St. Louis Prefectos | Sheldon Price | 22-26 (.458) |
| Federal League | Cleveland Green Sox | Michael Rudolph | 20-28 (.417) |
| Fenway Fenatics | Real Ballplayers Play Two | Alonda Clifton | 23-25 (.479) |
| Firemen League | Banta Fire | Andrew Lehman | 23-25 (.479) |
| Firemen League | Blue Earth Jolly Green Giants | Sam Campbell | 23-25 (.479) |
| Four Star League | Sink The Bismarck | Andrew Lehman | 18-30 (.375) |
| Four Star League | Stalag 33 & 1/3rd | Michael Lehman | 15-33 (.313) |
| Game Night League | Andreja Liked That | Sherman Wan | 22-26 (.458) |
| Game Night League | SoCal Blue Dogs | Scott Owens | 19-29 (.396) |
| Geek Pride League | Boba Chette and the Darksabers | Sherman Wan | 21-27 (.438) |
| Geek Pride League | Silicon Valley Ones And Zeroes | Sheldon Price | 22-26 (.458) |
| Gone But Not Forgotten League | Larry, Pedro, Kenny Hill and the 1994 Expos | Jason Kiernan | 22-26 (.458) |
| Gone But Not Forgotten League | Veeckville Gaedels | Anthony C | 12-36 (.250) |
| Grand Slam League | Moons Over My Hammy | Sherman Wan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Grand Slam League | Ultimate Taters | David Henning | 20-28 (.417) |
| Hall of Fame League | California Bears | Michael Quinn | 23-25 (.479) |
| Home of the Brave | I've Seen Your Face Before My Friend | Sherman Wan | 20-28 (.417) |
| Home of the Brave | Middle School Jocks | Bill Munger and Benchwarmer Baseball League Office | 21-27 (.438) |
| Marxball | Star City Novas | David Henning | 23-25 (.479) |
| Minnie & Paul League | Happy Campers | Alonda Clifton | 15-33 (.313) |
| Minnie & Paul League | Riverdale Robot Refugees | David Henning | 22-26 (.458) |
| Motor City League | Gratiot Cards | Michael Quinn | 20-28 (.417) |
| North Siders League | North Side Winders | Michael Lehman | 23-25 (.479) |
| North Siders League | Omaha Golden Spikes | Don Kruse | 21-27 (.438) |
| Original Six League | Powerplay Goals | Michael Lehman and Benchwarmer Baseball League Office | 19-29 (.396) |
| Perfect World League | Arkansas Hogs | Michael Quinn | 22-26 (.458) |
| Perfect World League | Malta Falcons | Sherman Wan | 20-28 (.417) |
| Phightin' Phils League | Chip Kelly Heroes | Tom McGraw | 21-27 (.438) |
| Phightin' Phils League | SGV Dukes | Michael Quinn | 23-25 (.479) |
| Phightin' Phils League | The 1993 Philadelphia Phillies Men Injecting Men 5 | Christian Ingram | 19-29 (.396) |
| Reality Bites | America's Idols | Dave Matter | 18-30 (.375) |
| Reality Bites | Sea Isle City Sandsharks | Robert Elias | 22-26 (.458) |
| Royal Flush League | Bellevue Vikings | Michael Lehman | 20-28 (.417) |
| Silver Screen League | Avalon Dryads | John Stroba | 18-30 (.375) |
| South Siders League | Harry Carrys Misfits | Tom McGraw | 16-32 (.333) |
| South Siders League | South Pole Blizzard | Jason Kiernan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Steel City League | Hershey Special O.P.S. | David Henning | 21-27 (.438) |
| Superman League | Here Come da Judge | Michael Lehman | 21-27 (.438) |
| That's the Fact Jack League | Ty's Ties | Dave Matter | 15-33 (.313) |
| The Kings of Queens | Dunder Mifflin Sabres | Don Kruse | 20-28 (.417) |
| The Kings of Queens | Heffernan's Henchmen | Michael Rudolph | 21-27 (.438) |
| The Kings of Queens | Nevada Marshals | Mark Currie | 21-27 (.438) |
| They Might Be Giants | California Dreamin' Team | David Henning | 22-26 (.458) |
| Three of a Kind League | Equilateral Triangles | Michael Rudolph | 22-26 (.458) |
| Three of a Kind League | Motor City Gamblers | Tom McGraw | 17-31 (.354) |
| Tobacco Road League | Carmel Surfer Boys | Andrew Lehman | 22-26 (.458) |
| Tobacco Road League | Durham Dragonwings | John Stroba | 21-27 (.438) |
| Triple Crown League | Hobart Hurricanes | Michael Rudolph | 22-26 (.458) |
| Wes Anderson League | Hollywood Limelights | Anthony C | 23-25 (.479) |
| Whiff League | Peaches of Longevity | Jim Duzyk | 15-33 (.313) |
| Whiff League | Spaceman Spiff | John Hula | 23-25 (.479) |
| White Elephant League | Dark Side of the Moon Over Miami Marlins | Andrew Lehman | 19-29 (.396) |
| Will Ferrell League | Buddy the Elf Plays Every Position | Jason Kiernan | 23-25 (.479) |
| Will Ferrell League | Daytona Shake 'n Bake | Jerry Stevens | 22-26 (.458) |
| Winners Circle League | Angel Cats | Dave Matter | 19-29 (.396) |
