Resolving Contested Draft Picks

First up, Joey Votto (Salary 3502)

Between Cincinnati and California, there are several tiebreakers that come into play, but both teams already were awarded relief pitchers as their only player, so we come down to the tiebreaker of draft rank.  California didn't rank Votto at all, so he goes to Cincinnati.

Yu Darvish (2777)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Kentucky	42700	2	6
Cuyahoga	41483	1	11
The Flats	40874	1	12
Shaky Heights	40058	1	9
Cincinnati	39398	2	13

Kentucky, based on cap room left.

Jason Kipnis (2179)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Cedar Point	42893	1	6
Wonton	42756	1	999
Cuyahoga	41483	1	16
Kentucky	39923	3	18
Cincinnati	39398	2	23

Based on cap room left, it's Cedar Point.  Unless otherwise noted, this is the reason for all player awards below.

Evan Longoria (1784)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
California	42900	1	999
Cuyahoga	41483	1	28
The Flats	40874	1	2
Shaky Heights	40058	1	6
Kentucky	39923	3	22

California

Paul Goldschmidt (1625)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Paridise Ohio	42403	3	4
Not So Hot	42389	2	3
Paradise Theatre	41348	1	999
The Flats	40874	1	6
Cedar Point	40714	2	4

Paridise Ohio

Todd Frazier (1043)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Wonton	42756	1	10
Toledo	42314	1	999
Rock-n-Roll	40638	1	1
Parma	40334	1	17
Cincinnati	39398	2	15

Wonton

Salvador Perez (579)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Toledo	42314	1	999
Paradise Theatre	41348	1	999
Lake Erie	41320	2	10
Cedar Point	40714	2	18
Rock-n-Roll	40638	1	16

Toledo

Adeiny Hechavarria (141)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Not So Hot	42389	2	10
Toledo	41735	2	999
Wonton	41713	2	18
Cuyahoga	41483	1	10
Paridise Ohio	40778	4	11

Not So Hot

Kyuji Fujikawa (100, P, "F")

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Not So Hot	42248	3	21
Cuyahoga	41483	1	14
The Flats	40874	1	31
Paridise Ohio	40778	4	21
Rock-n-Roll	40638	1	35

Not So Hot

Danny Hultzen (100, P, "H")

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Not So Hot	42148	4	11
Paradise Theatre	41348	1	8
Lake Erie	41320	2	3
Kentucky	39923	3	33
Cincinnati	39398	2	5

Not So Hot again

Mike Olt (100, 3B)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Paradise Theatre	41348	1	11
California	41116	2	999
The Flats	40874	1	32
Paridise Ohio	40778	4	31
Kentucky	39923	3	23

Paradise Theatre

13 players were picked by 4 teams.

Mike Trout (Salary 4279)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Paridise Ohio	40778	4	1
Cedar Point	40714	2	2
Kentucky	39923	3	1
Cincinnati	39398	2	17

Paridise Ohio

Matt Kemp (3647)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Calloway	41483	1	5
California	41116	2	999
Parma	40334	1	4
Shaky Heights	40058	1	2

Calloway

Tom Wilhelmsen (2371)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Toledo	41735	2	999
Wonton	41713	2	999
The Flats	40874	1	19
Shaky Heights	40058	1	12

Toledo

Kris Medlen (2291)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Cuyahoga	41483	1	12
Lake Erie	41320	2	20
Paradise Theatre	41248	2	5
The Flats	40874	1	13

Cuyahoga

Jason Grilli (1346)

Team	Cap Left	Total Players	Rank
Paradise Theatre	41248	2	999
Cedar Point	40714	2	7
Rock-n-Roll	40638	1	21
Toledo	39364	3	999

Paradise Theatre

The Flats

Cedar Point